Handling Conflicting Resume Advice
Dear Debra:
It seems like every person that reviews my resume gives me new advice. I’ve gone through about five major overhauls. One said, “Lose the summary.” A former manager told me I must present my 16 years of project management history on one page. Then there are the endless comments about font, all bullets, no bullets, and half bullets/half paragraph. My head is spinning. What do you suggest? I am concerned that these people won’t help me in my search (such as referrals) if I don’t follow their advice.
Thank you!
Jeri
Dear Jeri:
I don’t recommend “shopping” for resume advice, especially if you are asking people who are not resume experts. When you seek advice, seek the right expert for the situation. Your industry contacts are ideal people to consult regarding new opportunities, professional development suggestions, and networking. A professional resume writer is the best person to ask for resume advice.
If you are getting unsolicited resume advice that is contrary to professional advice that you’ve received, there are tactful ways to handle the situation. Thank your colleague and tell them that you will consider adopting their suggestions. If this colleague is presenting your resume and they insist on a particular format. Consider using that format for that situation only – unless it is a radical change, inconsistent with modern professional resume writing.
Regarding the examples you shared:
* Yes, summaries are standard on modern professional resumes. I recommend including it on all resumes.
* A long list of bullets only is often called, “death by bullets” because it is ineffective. A long paragraph without a bullets section is also less appealing to the readers. A mix of narrative and bullets is best in most cases.
* Page length varies based on the candidate. One-page is suitable for many entry-level candidates. However, most experienced candidates will find that two-pages is the perfect length. Some candidates with extensive education, publications, presentations, affiliations, and comprehensive work history may have a three-page resume.
Please feel free to send us your resume for a critique. I’d be happy to review it.
All the best,
Debra